Hello and welcome to CertForums.co.uk, here we host free active certification forums with links to the best free resources for Microsoft's MCSA MCSE MCDBA Cisco's CCNA CCDA and CCNP, and CompTIA's A+ Network+ i-NET+ and Security+ certifications in the UK. If you wish to post or use other advanced features you will need to register first. Registration is absolutely free and takes only a few minutes to complete so sign up today!

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact support

Go Back   CertForums > Certification Forums > Microsoft Certification Forums > General
Home Forums Register Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

MCSA or Server +

Post New ThreadReply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 02:57 PM
noel123ie noel123ie is offline
New Member
Posts: 27
Points: 0 noel123ie has no points
Power: 1
None
Join Date: 22 Aug 2008
MCSA or Server +

Hi there



I was wondering am I better just doing the mcsa or a mix.



Maybe do a+ and net+ which will count as an mcp.



I could do net+ and ser+ in local college and then the a+ in my own time.



I would then have one mcp(a+ and net+) and server+



Or I was wondering am I better just doing a+/net+( 1 mcp) and then keeping on mcsa route



This is whats covered in server+



Operating System Fundamentals
Windows 2000 and Network Operating Systems
Windows 2003
VMWare
Network Components and Security
TCP/IP Networking
Linux Installation and Administration
System Administration
TroubleShooting


Some exposure to linux etc



Thanks

Noel


Last edited by noel123ie : 26-Aug-2008 at 03:07 PM.
 
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 03:42 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Certification Guru
Posts: 12,462
Points: 6508 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 193
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 39
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
I was wondering am I better just doing the mcsa or a mix.
That depends on your experience level. If you have 6 months of real-world experience administering servers, then the MCSA is a great choice. If not, you should consider the A+, Network+, and MCDST certifications.

Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Maybe do a+ and net+ which will count as an mcp.
The A+ and Network+ can be used as an elective for the MCSA, but they will NOT grant you the MCP certification. The only thing that will grant you the MCP certification is taking any one of the older Microsoft exams (one from the Windows XP or Server 2003 track, not an MCTS or MCITP exam).

Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
I could do net+ and ser+ in local college and then the a+ in my own time.
You can save money and do ALL of them through self-study... at your own pace, on your own schedule.

Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
I would then have one mcp(a+ and net+) and server+
I would recommend doing the Server+ after you have some real-world experience with server administration. If you've got that, then great!

Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Or I was wondering am I better just doing a+/net+( 1 mcp) and then keeping on mcsa route
I would recommend starting with A+, Network+, and MCDST. When you have about 6 months of server admin experience, I'd recommend pursuing Server+ and the MCSA. Certifications without the appropriate amount of experience are not going to be very useful to you.


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 03:42 PM
Qs's Avatar
Qs Qs is offline
Semi-Honorary Member
Posts: 1,359
Points: 1292 Qs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 points
Power: 27
None
Join Date: 13 May 2008
Location: Lichfield, West Midlands
Age: 21
Certifications: HND Applied IT, CCNA
WIP: MCDST, MCP, A+, N+
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Hi there

I was wondering am I better just doing the mcsa or a mix.
MCSA is quite a high level Microsoft Certification so I suggest you start smaller and go for either CompTIA's A+, N+ or a MCDST if you're just starting out.

Link can be found below:-

CompTIA's A+

CompTIA's N+
MCDST

Also bear in mind that if you're aiming to burst into the IT field with no prior experience then potential employers won't look twice at you. You need both experience and qualifications. If you're going for a 1st line support role then the aforementioned links and referenced certs are the way to go.

Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie
Maybe do a+ and net+ which will count as an mcp.
No, it doesn't. I refer you to this thread.


Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie
I could do net+ and ser+ in local college and then the a+ in my own time.
That's a possibility. Pretty much all of the CompTIA certs can be done self-study though if you don't wish to pursue them through a college. I'd recommend going for the A+ and the N+ to start though as this will build up a knowledge base for higher level qualifications and will also bolster your CV without becoming over-certified.


Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie
I would then have one mcp(a+ and net+) and server+
No, you wouldn't. See the aforementioned link.


Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie
Or I was wondering am I better just doing a+/net+( 1 mcp) and then keeping on mcsa route
It's entirely up to you, we can only offer advice. (Plus.. It won't count as an MCP) The A+ and N+ is generally what the recommendation is for people wishing to obtain a 1st line support/helpdesk role though. Such roles also build up your experience for higher level jobs (2nd line etc)


Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie
This is whats covered in server+



Operating System Fundamentals
Windows 2000 and Network Operating Systems
Windows 2003
VMWare
Network Components and Security
TCP/IP Networking
Linux Installation and Administration
System Administration
TroubleShooting



Some exposure to linux etc



Thanks

Noel
Well if that appeals to you then go for it. Any experience with servers is useful and I for one wouldn't discourage going for additional qualifications if they're beneficial to you. My recommendation though is to get some experience (volunteer for IT related roles - helping out at your local college etc) and put it on your CV, and concentrate on smaller fish (A+, N+ etc) before going after the whales (MCSA).

Don't ya just love metaphors?

Hope this helps.

Qs




Base 8 is just like Base 10, if you are missing two fingers.

Last edited by Qs : 26-Aug-2008 at 03:45 PM.
 
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 03:43 PM
Qs's Avatar
Qs Qs is offline
Semi-Honorary Member
Posts: 1,359
Points: 1292 Qs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 points
Power: 27
None
Join Date: 13 May 2008
Location: Lichfield, West Midlands
Age: 21
Certifications: HND Applied IT, CCNA
WIP: MCDST, MCP, A+, N+
Michael! Curse you and your better than average typing speed! I now have to scroll down a lot more to read my reply

Qs




Base 8 is just like Base 10, if you are missing two fingers.
 
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 03:56 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Certification Guru
Posts: 12,462
Points: 6508 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 193
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 39
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Qs View Post
Michael! Curse you and your better than average typing speed! I now have to scroll down a lot more to read my reply

Qs
You can't always be first, my friend. ;) Not with Mr. Speedy Fingers over here across the pond.

Would it help if I repped your post? Sorry, couldn't resist! heehee!!!


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 04:01 PM
Qs's Avatar
Qs Qs is offline
Semi-Honorary Member
Posts: 1,359
Points: 1292 Qs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 pointsQs has over 1000 points
Power: 27
None
Join Date: 13 May 2008
Location: Lichfield, West Midlands
Age: 21
Certifications: HND Applied IT, CCNA
WIP: MCDST, MCP, A+, N+
Quote:
Originally Posted by BosonMichael View Post
You can't always be first, my friend. ;) Not with Mr. Speedy Fingers over here across the pond.

Would it help if I repped your post? Sorry, couldn't resist! heehee!!!
*sulks*

... I found it quite scary how similar our replies were as a matter of fact. I swear it's the wireless that slowed down my posting speed *grr*




Base 8 is just like Base 10, if you are missing two fingers.
 
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 06:02 PM
noel123ie noel123ie is offline
New Member
Posts: 27
Points: 0 noel123ie has no points
Power: 1
None
Join Date: 22 Aug 2008
Thanks

Hi

I already work in an IT company(call centre) and have a diploma in IT support so have a good basic knowledge of networks

Would the mcsa not look better on a cv?

Thanks
Noel

 
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 06:23 PM
wagnerk's Avatar
wagnerk wagnerk is offline CertForums News Posting Member
In memory of UCM...
Posts: 4,853
Points: 4208 wagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 pointswagnerk has over 4000 points
Power: 97
Join Date: 13 May 2005
Location: Northants, UK
Age: 30
Certifications: 2nd Degree Black Belt
WIP: Thinking of GCGI/MSc in the future
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Hi

I already work in an IT company(call centre) and have a diploma in IT support so have a good basic knowledge of networks

Would the mcsa not look better on a cv?

Thanks
Noel
The MCSA is geared towards people that meet the below:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Microsoft
Candidates for the MCSA on Windows Server 2003 certification typically have 6 to 12 months of experience administering client and network operating systems. They are knowledgeable about implementing, managing, and maintaining the typically complex computing environment of mid-sized to large companies.
And not just 6 months on helpdesk. Professional certifications aren't to be used as a short-cut or a replacement for experience at that level. Unfortunately because lots of people are gaining these certifications that are there to validate your experience, alot of managers (including myself) are now over-looking these certs if your work experience doesn't back them up.

Sorry to be harsh, but in the classes that I've taught in the last academic year, I've had MCSA's & MCSE's that had these creds but were absolutely clueless when it came to do the simple things like joining a PC to a domain.

-Ken


IT Manager, IT Writer/Columist & Part-time IT Lecturer
 
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 26-Aug-2008, 07:04 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Certification Guru
Posts: 12,462
Points: 6508 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 193
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 39
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Hi

I already work in an IT company(call centre) and have a diploma in IT support so have a good basic knowledge of networks

Would the mcsa not look better on a cv?

Thanks
Noel
Not if you don't have experience, no. In fact, being overcertified for your experience level can actually hurt, not help, your chances of getting a job. Employers with MCSA-level jobs won't hire you because you have the experience, and employers with entry-level jobs may not hire you because they really don't need someone with MCSA-level qualifications to do an entry-level job. Thus, you can put yourself into an unemployable situation (unless you leave the MCSA off your resume - and if that's the case, why pursue it at this stage of your career?).


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 27-Aug-2008, 07:55 AM
noel123ie noel123ie is offline
New Member
Posts: 27
Points: 0 noel123ie has no points
Power: 1
None
Join Date: 22 Aug 2008
CCNA

Hi there

I also went to local college and saw a presentation on CCNA

I was very impressed with the lecturer and also I would have covered some of this on my diploma course

I also see CCNA on alot of job ads

Any help would be great
Noel


Last edited by noel123ie : 27-Aug-2008 at 07:56 AM.
 
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 27-Aug-2008, 08:26 AM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Certification Guru
Posts: 12,462
Points: 6508 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 193
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 39
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Hi there

I also went to local college and saw a presentation on CCNA

I was very impressed with the lecturer and also I would have covered some of this on my diploma course

I also see CCNA on alot of job ads

Any help would be great
Noel
In my opinion, the CCNA is even MORE advanced than the MCSA - it's designed for people who are starting to get some real-world network administration experience with Cisco devices. It will not be of much use to you at the beginning of your IT career.

Sounds like you're trying to find a "shortcut" or "fast track" in IT. The problem with that is... unless you've got an uncle who is an IT manager, there really *isn't* a shortcut. You start out with an entry-level IT job, and you work your way up. And to get an entry-level job, you need entry-level certifications, such as the A+, Network+, and MCDST. If you want to get a job as an IT tech, there aren't any other certifications that will help you out other than those three when you're just starting out.

Best of luck to you!


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 01-Sep-2008, 02:33 PM
noel123ie noel123ie is offline
New Member
Posts: 27
Points: 0 noel123ie has no points
Power: 1
None
Join Date: 22 Aug 2008
Update and thanks

Hi there

Thanks for all the info guys

Spoke to guy in college who give CCNA- this is a government college so this guy makes nothing from this

He also had 62 people for 38 places so no reason for him to push me towards course.

I asked him whether i would have knowledge required to complete course and he said yes as part of diploma.

So i decided to go with this- in the meantime I have 1 year to get a job on helpdesk etc so I will not be someone ccna certified with no practical experience.

Thanks
Noel

 
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 01-Sep-2008, 04:07 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Certification Guru
Posts: 12,462
Points: 6508 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 193
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 39
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by noel123ie View Post
Hi there

Thanks for all the info guys

Spoke to guy in college who give CCNA- this is a government college so this guy makes nothing from this

He also had 62 people for 38 places so no reason for him to push me towards course.

I asked him whether i would have knowledge required to complete course and he said yes as part of diploma.

So i decided to go with this- in the meantime I have 1 year to get a job on helpdesk etc so I will not be someone ccna certified with no practical experience.

Thanks
Noel
If you're getting a job on helpdesk, then even after a year, you won't likely have any practical experience with Cisco. Administering Cisco routers is a network admin responsibility... about three steps past helpdesk. (help desk > desktop support > server admin > network admin)


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #14